|
CAUTION: SWINDLERS, or "Path to the Success"
Tortuous path of the breeder ... but nothing terrible or dangerous
about it, if he is honest and open. Error, the wrong steps,
unjustified expectations - almost every breeder had that.
The choice of the path - it’s a personal decision of the breeder.
Sometimes different paths lead to a similar results - getting high
quality dogs with a good mentality and temperament.
But sometimes the breeder selects a very strange ( for a normal
human perception ) path - a path of fraud and deception.
It’s the choice that made Irina Komolova (kennel "Busher Plus").
Over 10 years of activity in the breed did not bring any significant
results in quality of her dogs. Only quantity .But one day she
decided that luck turned her way - just take "under the wing" the
owner of some dogs of kennel Zon Mirekl breeding.Dogs without full
documents, for the reason that owner ( Kosova) didn’t fulfill the
agreement.That was easily corrected by Komolova by getting puppies
out of those dogs, and substituting their own documents . Each one
of this duo dishonest people got what they wanted. Komolova - dogs
with a long-desired bloodline and type, and Kosova - dogs with the
documents, "Busher Plus" in this case.
In the previous article I provided numerous evidence of those
activities, based on many facts and testimony of different people.
As well as photographs showing the similarity of the dogs of
different bloodlines (by their records)
In these photos you can see two dogs from kennel "Zon Mirekl " and
two dogs from kennel "Busher Plus”. In these photographs dogs
positioned in a similar angle. I have repeatedly seen those dogs at
the shows and I can say that this similarity is not just due to the
same poses.
My suspicions started in early 2009 and I began to collect the
evidences. I tracked all the litters of "Busher Plus," kept all the
photos and information on those litters, which used dogs of my
breeding, but on documents have "Busher Plus" prefix.
When evidences were sufficient to leave no doubt that I was right in
my suspicions, I published this information on my website and urged
Komolova to do genetic examination on selected dogs. I offered to
pay for all expenses involved.Moral character and opportunity of
Komolova , if desired, to falsify the results, led me to offer an
open procedure for DNA testing at reputable laboratory.We found such
in France,who is working with the maximum of genetic markers.
On May 20 ,2011 I have ordered and paid for a sufficient number of
kits for genetic testing.It was reported to Komolova with the
requirement to provide the dogs out of litter "M" parents born in
2009 as well as Zeguda Bushehr Plus Bugatti , Busher Plus Viva
Victoria and grandmother of both lines Busher Plus Gnomic
To monitor the correctness of the procedure was proposed to invite
neutral and trusted representatives as Makhanko and Khomasuridze .
And perhaps someone from the breeders.
Protocol for procedure was offered
as:
1.Acceptable for both parties veterinary clinic, date and time;
2 Signing protocol by witnesses with passport data;
3.Photo of the dogs, special markings – tattoo or microchips and
vetpasport.
4 Careful handling and packaging of samples.
5. Send samples by independent witnesses.
6. Designation of an independent receiver, who will notify all
interested parties.
7. Envelopes to be opened in the presence of interested parties and
independent witnesses.
Upon receipt of genetic maps I was ready to provide genetic maps of
close relatives (siblings and several of their parents), mother of
puppies for comparison and analysis. This would be done by genetic
laboratory in Israel that specializes on this type of work.
Out of fear of exposure and the collapse of her activities, Komolova
choose to go ahead with "quiet" testing. On May 26, 2011, knowing
that I ordered tests from France, she made testing of her dogs on he
own. To give weight to this procedure, she invited Makhanko (
president of our club) who was not informed about the purpose or
reason for her presence.
The whole procedure is raising a lot of questions. Here are some
facts:
In Russia we have one laboratory that provide DNA testing for
animals - "Zoogen", located in St. Petersburg. Zoogen can send kits
for independent sampling of the material and then they will be sent
back to "Zoogen" by mail for testing. "Zoogen" provide courier
services within the city and region of St.Petersburg only.
In Moscow, "Zoogen" has a partner for DNA testing -laboratory
"Chance Bio”,which only provide collection of the genetic material
and shipping it by mail to Zoogen for actual testing. “Chance Bio”
has a set route for their couriers and they come for pick ups
according to the schedule of the driver. No special delivery
services provided. According to the head of "Zoogen" St. Petersburg,
the laboratory tests are not legitimate in Europe and are not
recognized by RCF.
The procedure, carried out by Komolova appeared, according to
Makhanko , as:
1. Kits for testing were "at hand". (One would assume that she had
received them directly from the "Zoogen" or some European
laboratory)
2. The doctor was not informed in advance about the purpose of
upcoming procedure.
3. The observer (Makhanko ) was in the hallway all the time and saw
immediately identify the dog and procedures of the fence material.
4.Cloth, soaked with blood for DNA studies were dried out in the
hallway.
3.”Courier” appeared shortly after procedure was started and was
waiting in the lobby,talking to Komolova, until all materials were
available (As I mentioned before, "Chance Bio" laboratory do not
provide a special courier service, and "Zoogen" and European
laboratories do not have such services for Moscow region.While
waiting, Komolova and her companions had unrestricted access to the
samples and the possibility of replacing them. ( Right before the
testing, Komolova visited city of...- the present residence of the
mother of dogs in question.)
5. Exactly 3 weeks later, as it was “predicted” by Komolova, results
came with conformation of the parenting (interesting enough, it
takes "Zoogen"40 days to complete testing.)
The owner of two puppies from kennel "Bushehr Plus", Hermine Müller
from France ,was informed by Komolova about parentage conformation
for her puppies. I sent Hermine an email asking to share those
results with me and compare with results I had for my own dogs. She
did not respond.
Currently Komolova sending letters that I was misled and provided
false information by Vitalia Kamushenko –french bulldogs owner
living in Germany.
Indeed, Kamushenko contacted me after I published the first article
on the subject on my website. She confirmed that she was struck by
the similarity of my dogs and dogs from "Busher Plus" at World Dog
Show 2010 in Denmark. In Denmark,Komolova brought three puppies from
litter "M", born in June 2009 (Busher Pljus Magic Cloud, Busher
Pljus Make Me Crazy, Busher Pljus Moon Angel).
Kamushenko was told by Kosova, also present at the show,that those
puppies are part of the litter out of Zon Mirekl Mia Jolie Princess
(but registered under Busher Plus Viva Victoria as dam) and other
part of the litter end up with another dam of Busher Plus breeding.
Following the publication of the first article on my website Kosova
called Kamushenko,threatening, if she opens the truthful information
about the activities of Komolova with Kosova’s dogs of Zon Mirekl
origins.
This is further confirmed my suspicions.
It was atleast three more litters with prefix “Busher Plus” out of
Zon Mirekl dogs.Two from Zone Mirekl Mia Jolie Princess and one from
Zon Mirekl Mei Lu.
I urge all owners and buyers of puppies from kennel "Busher Plus"to
claim genetic maps from legitimate laboratories on the parents of
puppies born since 2009
I urge the owners of puppies from kennel "Busher Plus", which are
intended for breeding, to do genetic tests so further breeding
program will have less surprises.
In turn, I'm ready to give to compare genetic maps of my dogs - the
immediate family of puppies produced by Komolova out of dogs,
substituted by "Busher Plus" prefix.
I will do all possible to expose the activities of the owner kennel
"Busher Plus" Komolova as fraudulent and to prove it to the breed,
regardless of how long it will take. |